Allen Brothers Review

Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend things we believe are useful. Read our full disclosure.

What it is: USDA Prime steaks and gourmet meats shipped frozen from Chicago
Best for: Gift givers who want USDA Prime steaks
Price: Four 4-oz Prime filets $99.95 + $29.95 shipping, checked October 29, 2026
Prices checked: October 29, 2026

We researched Allen Brothers's official pricing, terms, product pages, help pages and outside reviews. We haven't used Allen Brothers ourselves, so this is a research-based review, not a hands-on test.

Who it’s best for

People sending a steak gift.
Cooks who want USDA Prime cuts.
Anyone who wants steaks delivered frozen and ready to store.

Who should skip it

Probably not the best fit if you want pasture-raised meat or a subscription discount, which Porter Road offers.

How it works day to day

This part draws on Allen Brothers’s own product pages, help center and documentation, read October 29, 2026 (listed under Sources). We haven’t used Allen Brothers ourselves.

Steaks arrive frozen in a cooler with dry ice; you move them to the freezer and thaw in the fridge before cooking.

Key features in use

USDA Prime steaks
Frozen shipping with dry ice
Gift packages
Next-day problem reporting

Setup and learning curve

None.

Integrations

None.

Support

Phone and email.

Real-world use cases

Holiday gifts
Special dinners
Stocking the freezer

What it costs

Prices checked October 29, 2026, from Allen Brothers’s own pricing page unless noted. Prices change often, so check the official page before you buy.

USDA Prime filet mignon: $99.95 for four 4-oz steaks.
Ships frozen with dry ice by UPS; standard 2-day shipping to the continental US is $29.95.
Guarantee: report a problem by the next business day after delivery for a replacement or gift card.

What we like

USDA Prime steaks.
Ships frozen with dry ice.
A long-running Chicago steakhouse supplier.
Clear shipping cost and guarantee.

What to watch for

Trustpilot showed 3.1 out of 5 from only 4 reviews as of October 29, 2026, too few to be meaningful.
Shipping adds $29.95.
You must report problems by the next business day.

The fine print

Guarantee gives a replacement or gift card, not necessarily cash.
Ships to the continental US.
Keep frozen until ready to cook.

The main alternative: Porter Road Reviewed by Vetteroo

What it costs: Bone-in ribeye $63 (about 1.2 lb); subscriptions 15% off, checked October 29, 2026

Read our full Porter Road review

Pick Allen BrothersReviewed by Vetteroo if you…

want USDA Prime.
are sending a gift.
want frozen steaks to store.

Pick Porter RoadReviewed by Vetteroo if you…

want pasture-raised meat.
want a subscription discount.

Our take

Allen Brothers sells USDA Prime steaks shipped frozen, a classic choice for gifts. Shipping adds $29.95, and you must report problems quickly. Compare Porter Road for pasture-raised, dry-aged meat.

Side by side

Company	Best for	Starting price	Trial / refund
Allen Brothers Reviewed by Vetteroo	Gift givers who want USDA Prime steaks	Four 4-oz Prime filets $99.95 + $29.95 shipping, checked October 29, 2026	Report problems the next business day
Porter Road Reviewed by Vetteroo	Cooks who want pasture-raised, dry-aged meat delivered	Bone-in ribeye $63 (about 1.2 lb); subscriptions 15% off, checked October 29, 2026	No returns on perishables; makes it right

From our company records. Check the official pages for current prices.

What we checked

Allen Brothers's pricing page and terms, read October 29, 2026
Allen Brothers's Trustpilot profile, read October 29, 2026
Porter Road's details: from its own Wave 14 draft review, read October 29, 2026
The other official pages listed under Sources (links checked October 29, 2026)

Sources

Visit Allen Brothers’s official site

How we review

We read the company's own terms, test the sign-up or booking steps where we can, and compare it with alternatives. A commission never changes what we write. Read our disclosure.